Defience Scene Portrayal

I would pick scene C. The group starts to beat the scout, and then Tuvia stops them. While watching the movie I thought that was going to happen. It feels like a more natural reaction to the spy instead of killing him. But, I do understand that they would be extremely mad at the German for hunting them (Jews) down and killing them. According to my own ethics i would not have put them killing the spy in the scene. Because its pointless killing. Tuvia stopping them would make more sense in the scene. He is the type of person that would not stand by and let them kill the spy like that.